The Gilgo Beach murders, a chilling mystery that has gripped the nation for over a decade, took a dramatic turn with the arrest of Rex Heuermann. Now, a hair stylist and makeup artist, Nikki Brass, has come forward claiming that she went on a date with Heuermann years ago, an experience she describes as terrifying. This revelation sheds new light on the suspected serial killer and raises questions about what could have happened if things had gone differently.
A Date With Terror: How Brass Encountered Rex Heuermann
Brass, who worked as an escort several years ago, revealed in an interview that she met Heuermann through an online platform. While she couldn’t recall the exact site due to the numerous platforms she utilized, she vividly remembers her interaction with him. Heuermann, who allegedly targeted escorts, insisted on meeting at his home in Massapequa. Sensing danger, Brass stood firm and convinced him to meet at a public location, The Steam Room restaurant in Port Jeff.
A Haunting Conversation: Heuermann’s Fixation on the Gilgo Beach Murders
During the date, what started as a normal conversation took a dark turn when Heuermann asked Brass if she was interested in true crime. As a true crime enthusiast herself, Brass initially felt a spark of excitement. However, this quickly faded as Heuermann steered the conversation toward the Gilgo Beach murders.
Brass revealed that Heuermann’s demeanor changed as he discussed the case. His posture straightened, a smirk played on his lips, and his eyes lit up with an unsettling excitement. He seemed almost “mentally orgasmic,” as Brass described it, as if he relished discussing the horrific details.
Heuermann speculated about how the killer might have disposed of the bodies, suggesting they could have been carried through the marsh or transported by boat at night. He even went as far as proposing that a police officer could have committed the crimes, using their authority to avoid suspicion.
Chilling Details: Heuermann’s Alleged Statements About the Killings
Even more disturbing were Heuermann’s alleged comments about the victims and the methods used to kill them. According to Brass, he callously referred to the victims as “just escorts” and “just prostitutes,” dehumanizing them and dismissing their lives.
Heuermann allegedly revealed specific details about the murders, including that the victims were strangled. He even suggested that a hammer would be a “quick and easy” way to kill, claiming that “one time” would be enough. This chilling statement sent shivers down Brass’s spine, as she realized the potential danger she was in.
Narrow Escape: Brass Trusting Her Instincts
As the date progressed, Heuermann became insistent that Brass return to his home. However, gripped by fear and a growing sense of unease, she declined. She had sent a text message to a friend, arranging to meet in the parking lot for safety.
When Heuermann walked Brass to her car, her friend’s presence visibly agitated him. Brass believes that had her friend not been there, Heuermann might have attempted to harm her.
A Decade of Fear and Validation
Brass has carried the weight of this encounter for years, confiding in friends about her belief that she had dined with the Gilgo Beach killer.
While the Suffolk County Police Department hasn’t officially confirmed whether they will interview Brass, her story provides a chilling glimpse into the mind of the man accused of these heinous crimes.